Monday, December 18, 2006

New Test Requirements



An editorial in the AJC this morning got me to thinking about our responsibilities as citizens. We require immigrants applying for citizenship to take a test on their knowledge of "the fundamental concepts of American democracy". Why shouldn't we all have to re-qualify on a regular basis?

We should have to pass a citizenship test as part of our filing of income taxes every year.

The facts are really depressing. A recent survey showed that although 52 percent of Americans could name at least two characters on "The Simpsons" only 28 percent could tell you two of the freedoms protected by the First Amendment. Sad. Another recent survey showed that 77 percent of Americans knew at least two of the Seven Dwarf's names but only 24 percent could name two Supreme Court Justices. In September the Annenberg Public Policy Center found that just two-thirds of Americans polled could identify all three branches of government and that only 55 percent were aware that the Supreme Court could rule laws passed by Congress unconstitutional. Finally, and the worst shame of all, is that fully 35 percent thought that the President had the Constitutional right to have the "final say" over Congress and the Judiciary.

Here is a question. Do you think it is right that these people have the right to vote?

That is why I am going to advocate for a citizenship validation test on all Federal Income tax returns. You have to pass it or your right to vote is revoked until you do. Nothing too tough. A few First Amendment questions. A few questions on Constitutional Law and maybe throw in a few Magna Carta questions as well as a few landmark law questions like the Civil Rights Act and such. Questions everyone who votes should be able to answer.

You know maybe if we had some sort of pre-qualification for voting in this country we might have a different leader right now. That is not a bad thing to contemplate as you ponder the testing.

I expect your support on this.

Monday, Monday

We are around just busy with work stuff. Hope everyone had a great weekend and are all ready for the slide into the holidays and a new year. Is it 2007 already? Time flies when....
Back later after I get all the real work put away. Gorgeous day here in Atlanta and it sure doesn't seem like it is almost Christmas when you see 70 degrees and sunshine in the middle of December.
What me worry?

Sunday, December 17, 2006

Local Color



If you would like to see how some of the historic homes here in Roswell, GA are decorated for Christmas. You can go to this link and play the Windows Media File. In the last home, Bulloch Hall is Madam Monk's effort using the Alice in Wonderland theme. For a moment you even get to her showing a pop up book. She has been decorating in this home for years as the representative of the Historical Society and each year is a different theme for the whole house. This year it was children's books and Madam is an Alice enthusiast. This year she even went to the Alice shop in Oxford, England to get stuff for the room while she was visiting friends in the U.K. She is also notorious for hiding Elvis somewhere in the decorations each year and part of the deal is trying to find "The King". This year he is in the chess set with all the Alice characters and of course he is in the King's position.

P.S. Bulloch Hall is on the National Register of Historic Places and is famous both for being one of the few antebellum homes in the south to survive Sherman's march to the sea and for being the family home of Mittie Bulloch who married Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. and became the mother of President Teddy Roosevelt.

Saturday, December 16, 2006

We Need More

We need more voices like Bill Richardson. He came out today and spoke the truth about John McCain. The call for more cannon fodder in Iraq is insanity and it is against the will of the vast majority of the American people and equally important the rest of the world. There is absolutely no way we can win in Iraq(whatever win means) using military force. McCain and his chorus of Lieberman and Graham are still absolutely wrong as they have been for four years. Iraq is toast, we fucked it up big time, screwed, blued and tattooed. Thank goodness there are some that will speak out against this insanity. Thanks Bill Richardson.

“The leading advocate for escalating the war is Senator John McCain. I have served with John in Congress and I respect him. But John McCain is wrong, dead wrong to think that we can solve Iraq’s political crisis through military escalation.”

“There are no quick or easy answers to the crisis in Iraq. Our choices are between bad options and worse ones. Some prefer military escalation. Some choose staying the course. These options are illusions. The only realistic choice we have is to stand down militarily and let the Iraqis stand up and face the political crisis which only they can resolve.”

Wasteland

I get links from Christy at Firedoglake and from Sumo at Sumo Merriment and it generates not one comment. More people comment on a single post at Firedoglake than stop by here in a year and a link generates no activity at all? I tested Haloscan and it seem to work. Very strange.
Things are usually pretty quiet around here on the weekend but jeebus what a wasteland.
Granted I insist I don't blog for the comments but it does kinda feel good when you know someone actually reads some of the stuff you post and it is especially nice when you can engage someone in a conversation and exchange ideas. Looks like I am going to have to take off the gloves and actually write something meaningful here.

Friday, December 15, 2006

How Bush the Grinch Stole Christmas

Christy Hardin Smith aka ReddHedd at Firedoglake is on the warpath over the ICE raids around the country and the resultant chaos and tragedy for the children involved. I am going to quote almost the entirety of her post since only Redd can spit fire like this... and she has already posted a follow-up. When an ex-prosecutor and new mother gets cranked up about the responsibilities of the law and children in cases such as this, especially when it seems this is lot of show boating on the government's side you can expect some fireworks. Here they are:

So, let's see what we have here: a meat-packing company with a history of skating immigration laws (and allegations of them having some sort of scheme to import illegal workers from Guatemala) skates out of this scot free thus far.

Meanwhile, a mere nine days away from Christmas, these kids get the present of their parents being seized and hauled away, unable to contact them to let them know they are okay — with no time to make arrangements for their children's care.

And, in one case, a mother who was nursing her child is dragged off and cannot be located, while the child is left to deal with the consequences of being weaned against it's will by governmental agents. Which, as someone who has breastfed a child, is not something that should be done aburptly — and can have serious health consequences for the child, considering those first few months of breastfeeding provide the best portion of immunity protection and DHA for the child's developing brain [...]

Family values party, my ass.

If they were truly concerned with these childrens' welfare, they would have coordinated with local authorities and social services supervisors so that mechanisms were in place for temporary foster care placements and other service implementation, including the mound of paperwork that will now need to be processed to get these kids medical cards, temporary food and clothing assistance and other help — because they are US citizens and CHILDREN, and ought not be simply left standing outside their homes with no one to care for them. That is unconscionable and yet another example of piss poor planning by the DHS. Heckuva job, Mikey!

Beyond that, though, background checks, priors checks and other considerations will need to be taken into account for adults who are, at least temporarily anyway, caring for these children who have been left behind. The last thing you want is for these kids to be taken in by some seemingly caring adult…who happens to have a long history of pedophelia or violent tendencies or what have you. (Yes, I have been down this road before in abuse and neglect cases…and you do not even want to know what can happen to children in a placement that turns out to be a nightmare.)

That authorities in Texas are saying "Not my problem. The Feds are going to have to deal with this." is frightening — because the Feds are likely passing the buck right back to the locals. Which means the kids have had to scramble to find an adult to care for them on their own…and that can often lead to the very thing that no child should ever — EVER — have to survive.

And that is just for starters. According to the Dallas article, Texas authorities have no idea how many children may actually be stranded and/or affected by this. Well, that's encouraging, isn't it?

You tell 'em Christy.

Going Forward Wrongly

It is looking more and more like Bush is going to try and 'double down' in his effort to salvage his vision of a legacy in Iraq. St. John McCain is calling for more troops and so is Lieberman.
The calls for 40,000 thousand more troops in Iraq and $100 billion more to surge and 'win' is a most vicious pipe dream on the part of the neo-cons and Bush.

The problem in Iraq is a 500,000 man job and an additional 40,000 feet on the ground is just going to piss the Iraqis off. I guess it is human nature not to admit defeat but to think that we have any choice in what is going on in Iraq is delusional. There are 27 million Iraqis, and some 6 million of them in the Sunni Arab areas. 40,000 US troops is a drop in the bucket. Some of the insiders have now decided that the US should try to destroy the (Shiite) Mahdi Army. We might have had a chance and marginalizing them 3 years ago but since that time the Mahdi Army has grown and is now an urban social movement. It is almost impossible to destroy such a movement by conventional military means. If Bush takes this track we will see a real disaster compared to the last four years.

We have come to the point where all you can say is that we are now officially in an 'elective dictatorship". In spite of the overwhelming call for backing out of Iraq issued by the voters in November we are looking at just the opposite. We are currently spending $2 billion a week in Iraq according to recent estimates but that is just the tip of the iceberg. Both the Army and the Navy are saying they each need an addition $20 billion next year to fix the damage caused by the war and replace equipment and the Air Force is looking at a shortfall of $160 billion over the next 6 years. This is on top of the current $514 billion dollar defense budget. This is more spent on defense than the rest of the world combined. We now hear that Bush is going to ask Congress for an additional $100 billion early next year for Iraq. It is absolutely insane.

We are closing in on 3,000 American soldiers dead in Iraq and over 22,000 wounded. The illusion that there is a military way out of the quagmire is seen by the American public for the delusion that it is and they voted to end it. We are now about to see George Bush ignore the clear will of the people and continue to stay the course. I never wanted to live in an empire.

Thursday, December 14, 2006

American Travesty

Commenter T.G. pointed out this article by George Monbiot which ran in The Guardian on 12/12 concerning abuse being administered by Americans against Americans and others. Here is a little taste.

Last week, defence lawyers acting for Jose Padilla, a US citizen detained as an “enemy combatant”, released a video showing a mission fraught with deadly risk – taking him to the prison dentist. A group of masked guards in riot gear shackled his legs and hands, blindfolded him with black-out goggles and shut off his hearing with headphones, then marched him down the prison corridor(1).

Is Padilla really that dangerous? Far from it: his warders describe him as so docile and inactive that he could be mistaken for “a piece of furniture”. The purpose of these measures appeared to be to sustain the regime under which he had lived for over three years: total sensory deprivation. He had been kept in a blacked-out cell, unable to see or hear anything beyond it. Most importantly, he had no human contact, except for being bounced off the walls from time to time by his interrogators. As a result, he appears to have lost his mind. I don’t mean this metaphorically. I mean that his mind is no longer there.

This is being done to an American citizen who has been held for years without having his day in court. The government dropped the "dirty bomb" charges and are now holding him on some vague helping terrorist charge. This, of course, after the Supreme Court made them. This is not getting any play in the media and so therefore most Americans aren't even aware that this is happening. While Padilla is a high visibility situation this kind of torture is going on in prisons around the country and has been for years. Here is another excerpt from the Monbiot article"
But Padilla’s treatment also reflects another glorious American tradition: solitary confinement. Some 25,000 US prisoners are currently held in isolation – a punishment only rarely used in other democracies. In some places, like the federal prison in Florence, Colorado, they are kept in sound-proofed cells and might scarcely see another human being for years on end(9). They may touch or be touched by no one. Some people have been kept in solitary confinement in the United States for more than 20 years.

Only if you read The Guardian and other foreign papers and websites are you going to be made privy to this stuff. If you rely on the American press you are going to be a "Low Information" person. Go the Monbiot.com site and read the whole thing if you are in the mood to be really pissed off.

Amazing Bloody Catastrophe

This quote from Timothy Garton Ash in The Guardian pretty much sums up the situation as far as I can see.

What an amazing bloody catastrophe. The Bush administration's policy towards the Middle East over the five years since 9/11 is culminating in a multiple train crash. Never in the field of human conflict was so little achieved by so great a country at such vast expense. In every vital area of the wider Middle East, American policy over the last five years has taken a bad situation and made it worse.

If the consequences were not so serious, one would have to laugh at a failure of such heroic proportions - rather in the spirit of Zorba the Greek who, contemplating the splintered ruins of his great project, memorably exclaimed: "Did you ever see a more splendiferous crash?" But the reckless incompetence of Zorba the Bush has resulted in the death, maiming, uprooting or impoverishment of hundreds of thousands of men, women and children - mainly Muslim Arabs but also Christian Lebanese, Israelis and American and British soldiers. By contributing to a broader alienation of Muslims it has also helped to make a world in which, as we walk the streets of London, Madrid, Jerusalem, New York or Sydney, we are all, each and every one of us, less safe. Laugh if you dare.

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Made it Back

Even though someone ate the bread crumbs I had left to follow home I made it back. Actually caught and earlier flight and got upgraded to boot. A good travel day overall. Getting caught up on the other stuff.

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Not the Answer

Steve Bates over at Yellow Doggerel Democrat has the following factoid from Neal Pierce in a post about the "Drug War".
There are 2.2 million Americans behind bars, another 5 million on probation or parole, the Justice Department reported on Nov. 30. We exceed Russia and Cuba in incarcerations per 100,000 people; in fact, no other nation comes close. The biggest single reason for the expanding numbers? Our war on drugs — a quarter of all sentences are for drug offenses, mostly nonviolent.

This is really a pretty depressing piece of information. While I was in the service in the early 70's I spent some time as a drug counselor and got the opportunity to witness first hand the things in peoples' lives that lead them to try and solve them with drugs. It didn't take me long to realize that the "War on Drugs" was a joke. Punishment and incarceration addressed none of the problems that enabled drug use. It didn't even remove the subjects from exposure to drugs as they were just as available in jail or prison. We, as a society, are doing a great disservice to those in our society who turn to drugs for answers when we ignore the root causes and think that punishment is the answer. This is stupid. We could probably save ourselves a lot of tax money if we shifted our focus to the societal pressures that lead to drug abuse and addressed some of the fundamental causes instead.

Band-Aid Moment

My work here is finished and I am safely ensconced in the Marriott. I have been watching the goings on at CNN. So far I have seen Hillary, Dennis, Al, Obama and Jim Bakker's evangelical punk son. It is all rather depressing. I only watch CNN when I am trapped in hotel rooms with no Food Channel so it is always rather shocking when you really start seeing the content that serves so many Americans their daily diet of news. It is no wonder that "low information" is the perfect definition of most Americans. That must be why I spend so much time in the blogosphere. (the blogger spell checker doesn't like "blogosphere" btw).

Not really a point to this post other that some random thoughts on what is bubbling through my head tonight, so don't expect a memorable treatise on anything special.

What is becoming clear is that the Bush administration has decided that the best way to deal with the ISG report is to let it die a slow death and not even address "Finding A New Way Forward" until after the holidays. I think they are hoping that some miracle happens between now and then and there won't be a need for radical change or in other words that "stay the course" will make more sense after we have stuffed and spent ourselves into oblivion between now and 2007.

More and more I am sensing that the Dems are going to fail us on Iraq when they engage in January. Pelosi is saying that she will not use the budget knife to castrate Bush's war and is signaling that we will continue to approve funding for the misadventure. This, I think, is a mistake. If Bush gets his funding he will continue to try and "win" this thing even though most Americans have joined us traitors on the progressive left in knowing that this is no longer and never has been a militarily winnable "thing". The day we invaded Iraq for no reason we lost.

No, I think we are at the point now that we have to realize that we are dealing with the equivalent of an alcoholic and we have to stop enabling him. We have to let him hit the bottom and look up from the gutter and finally internalize the reality of his predicament and then ask for help. Never forget that he is just a "dry drunk" who has never addressed the issues and personality flaws that lead him to medicate himself into oblivion for the first 40 years of his life.
If the Democrats vote to continue funding for this fiasco then they have just bought themselves a used and thoroughly screwed up war from GWBush. If they fund it they own it.

We are at the point now where we have to make some very hard decisions and the first one is to stand aside and say no more. We will pay to bring the troops home but we will not pay to have them stay for one minute more than is necessary for a sane and safe withdrawal. We have been shown over and over that the Iraqi are not going to "stand up" and we are now just spending lives and treasure training the people who will try and kill us and their countrymen next week or month.

The idea that we can find a non-military solution by trying to find a "good Shiite faction" to support and then use them to marginalize Sadr is just wishful thinking. We have spent the last couple of years training and equipping his army. We are already seeing Sunni neighbors react to this possibility with threats of funding Iraq Sunni and calling for armed conflict against Shiites. It is too late to pick sides in Iraq. We have now reached the point where our only viable alternative is to cut our losses and apologize to Iraq and rest of the world for our foolishness and false bravado.

This is not going to be easy but sooner or later you reach those "band-aid" moments where you just have to do it fast and get the pain out of the way as quickly as possible.

Still Here

I am still here but just very busy. They should have scheduled me for a couple of more days here. Two days is just not long enough to gather enough information and tweak and test. Looks like it will be another 13 or 14 hour day and I will still have to leave somethings undone.
I did manage to get a backup of the client's database and will be able to continue testing after I leave. The only trouble is that this client is the last one on this version of software and I will be testing on the latest which is packed with a lot more functionality than the installed one. Interestingly, I can run the entire client application on my laptop faster than their server based version runs.

Oh well so much for techy talk. Good weather for this trip...high fifties in the afternoon which is very nice for this time of year in Mass. Could be cold and snowing.
In the small amount of news I am catching while getting ready it looks like things are still in the toilet in Iraq with 60+ blasted this morning while standing around looking for work. I bet their families are really glad that Bush is looking for a "New Way Forward". I am afraid to say that I have to constantly guard myself from getting hardened to this daily dose of bad news. It is really easy to start accepting the constant barrage of tragedy as the status quo. I am sure the Whitehouse crowd is expecting and counting on a large number of Americans to become desensitized to this ongoing tragedy and that is why they are so angry at the media for reminding us daily that the war is still going on. Of course, the media is not doing a very good job of really showing us the depth of the insanity and pain the Iraqi people are experiencing and it is not really hitting home as it should. The front page of the papers and the first thing on the evening news should be on the loss of American and Iraqi lives.

Well, time to get my self in gear and get to the client. Fortunately it is just around the corner from the hotel and I don't have to get out on the turnpike. Traffic is pretty brutal at rush hour around here.

Everyone have a great day.

Sunday, December 10, 2006

Hitting the Road

Updated below:

On the way to Boston in a bit. Looks like I'll have some decent weather for the couple of days there. A couple of interesting things happening in the news today.

Cold-Cash Jefferson has won his runoff. WTF?

Shuttle Discovery is away safely. Way to go.

the Iraqi president rejects the Baker report. Coulda told ya!

See you on the flip side.

Update: Here we are in Westborough Mass. If you are planning a trip to Boston in the near future be prepared for the worst traffic nightmare you can imagine. Once you leave the Ted Williams tunnel you are going to be in the middle of the big dig and it has been taking steroids. There are multiple turns and switchbacks pointing to 90W but just when you think you are getting there there is another turn. Seemed to take forever. Just a warning.

A busy two days so posting will be light. Have fun out there.

Saturday, December 09, 2006

Meandering

Saturday night and nothing much going on in the Fallenmonk household. Very cold here today and that is challengingMadam has gone to bed and yours truly tried to watch several different movies on cable but all of them just didn't ring the bell. It still amazes me that I have over a 100 channels to choose from and regularly cannot find anything of interest.

Spent a good part of the day putting together my power point presentation for Monday and Tuesday. This client is running a fairly old version of our product and I am tasked with convincing them that they should upgrade. There have been some revolutionary changes in the product since they implemented and I am seriously concerned about having enough time to cover all the stuff.

Not looking forward to flying to Boston tomorrow. The flight is not too bad but getting out of Boston and to the client in Westborough is brutal. The big dig is still very much a presence and as a results there are a lot of changes from my last visit.

Interesting note: my roundtrip airfare from Atlanta to Boston is only $168. My hotel in Mass is 169/night. What is wrong with this picture?

Friday, December 08, 2006

Just Do It


If you have you ever gone to bed hungry or were not sure if you could feed your family their next meal then quit reading this post right now and go over to the Campbell's Soup “Click for Cans” website. I won't cost you anything and you can vote for your favorite NFL team in the process. The city whose team wins will get a major donation to the city's food bank from Campbell's. The details are on the website.

A missed paycheck or worse a lost job, an illness, or any number of other things can cause us to have to rely on the kindness of neighbors. The bread line is closer than any of us would like to admit. From personal experience I can guarantee you that you know someone who is using (or has used) a food bank or food pantry to make ends meet. I am no stranger to the giant logs of process cheese or the canned chickens passed out by the government. They got my family through some hard times.

While I could care less about the NFL, I do care about hunger and so does Campbell's. They are a major corporate donor to food banks all year long not just during this promotion.They have a serious corporate commitment to fighting hunger.

Make sure and bookmark the site as you can vote once a day. P.S. If you know how to clear cookies in your browser you can vote more often :-) . And know that regardless of which team you vote for, you are helping someone in need. It's worth a minute of your time, once a day, for the next week.

This is so easy anyone can do it. Give it a try. Campbell's Soup “Click for Cans” website.

h/t to the All Spin Zone via Susie

Frigid Day in Hotlanta

21 degrees in Atlanta this morning which is pretty unusual. Been out to feed the birds (and squirrels) and to thaw out the bird baths. The squirrels had gathered up sticks and had a little fire in an old clay flower pot and five or six were huddled around and just looked at me while I filled the feeders. Their tails come in handy on these kind of days as they can use them as little scarves. It always amazes me that the tiny little bare legs on the chickadees and wrens don't just seize up on these kind of days. Should warm up a bit later and we might even see a more normal 45 or 50.
Time for a cuppa tea.

Thursday, December 07, 2006

More Good News on the Future

WASHINGTON - In a "sneak peak" revealing a grim side effect of future warmer seas new NASA satellite data find that the vital base of the ocean food web shrinks when the world's seas get hotter.

And that discovery has scientists worried about how much food marine life will have as global warming progresses.

The data show a significant link between warmer water — either from the El Nino weather phenomenon or global warming — and reduced production of phytoplankton of the world's oceans, according to a study in Thursday's journal Nature.

Phytoplankton are the microscopic plant life that zooplankton and other marine animals eat, essentially the grain crop of the world's oceans.

Study lead author Michael Behrenfeld, a biological oceanographer at Oregon State University, said Wednesday that the recent dramatic drop in phytoplankton production in much of the world's oceans is a "sneak peak of how ocean biology" will respond later in the century with global warming.

"Everything else up the food web is going to be impacted," said oceanographer Scott Doney of the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute. He was not involved in the study.

"What's worrisome is that small changes that happen in the bottom of the food web can have dramatic changes to certain species at higher spots on the food chain," Doney said.

Mr. Clean Strikes Again


Oh My! The Bush administration has just discovered that we have lowered lead pollution in our atmosphere by some 90 percent in the last quarter century and are quickly stepping in to correct this grave situation. Bush EPA officials assured the media that we can quickly reverse this trend and get the levels back to the levels we enjoyed twenty five years ago. (snark)

WASHINGTON (AP) - The Bush administration is considering doing away with health standards that cut lead from gasoline, widely regarded as one of the nation’s biggest clean-air accomplishments.

Battery makers, lead smelters, refiners all have lobbied the administration to do away with the Clean Air Act limits.

A preliminary staff review released by the Environmental Protection Agency this week acknowledged the possibility of dropping the health standards for lead air pollution. The agency says revoking those standards might be justified “given the significantly changed circumstances since lead was listed in 1976″ as an air pollutant.

The EPA says concentrations of lead in the air have dropped more than 90 percent in the past 2 1/2 decades.
h/t to Susie

Turd Polishing


UPDATED below with Russ Feingold's comment on the ISG(h/t Atrios via Kos)

Ok…I have had some time to digest The Iraq Study Group report and my considered opinion is that it is worthless, outside of a total repudiation of the Bush execution of this war of choice. If you are one of those few that still harbor some hope that magic is possible in Iraq then this report may come as a shock. We now have it confirmed by “experts” that "Stay the Course" is a massive failure and that Iraq is all but lost. The report’s purpose, which was to legitimize “Official Washington” inside the belt-line opinion and reconcile it with the rest of the countries’, is now complete.

You would think though, that with all the time on their hands the “experts” on the panel would have helped us understand how Iraq fits into the big picture. How does continuing the course in Iraq impact our national security? While the report does touch on how serious the Israel/Palestine conflict is and the need for the U.S. to engage countries in the region it doesn't address how our global foreign policy is affected or how the Iraq war has damaged our international legitimacy and our long-term national security. The only acceptable aspect of the report is that it confirms and legitimizes what we on the progressive, anti-war left have been saying for years not because it's anything new or especially insightful.

What is difficult to understand is whether the ISG report represents merely incompetence or just a lack of courage on the part of Baker and Hamilton. I had mistakenly understood the purpose of the report as an effort to put a fresh set of eyes and brains on the problem and define the current situation in Iraq, its impact on our global position and then how to best move forward. As I suspected, we have been sorely used once again. Everything about the report is merely political positioning and a hackneyed attempt by the current ruling elite to make whatever solution the best “political” solution. They seem to give a whit about the fact that on the day they released the report 10 American soldiers died in Iraq.

Instead of looking at the disaster in Iraq through the clear lens of reality and then letting the observations drive the conclusions they fell back on the political. They didn’t make the hard decisions that are required by this debacle and instead addressed the political positions and potential political ramifications of the various options. Instead of offering the best solution or options they chose to offer what they thought would be most politically saleable. Instead of just telling us the truth and spreading a clear and understandable picture of the situation for all of us to see they chose political expediency. These “experts” took eight months to tell us what we all already knew…Iraq is a mess and as Al Gore says the “the worst strategic disaster in American history”.


Finally, if it’s hollowness and political “chicken dancing” were not enough the report has no muscles. Because it is a product of political pressures and not reality it is spineless. Bush and Cheney can now just cherry pick the least politically onerous parts and create some hybridized version that let’s them do what they want and still claim that they are adhering to the report. If you need any proof of exactly how Bush is going to respond to this report I only have to point toward the 9/11 Commission Report. If you’ll remember, the Bush administration resisted the commission until they had no choice and then picked pieces from it while ignoring the most important suggestions and now claim to have implemented it. This is a precedent I fully expect to be followed in this case.

Here we are again. We have waited 8 months for this report and once again we are left with nothing but essentially a political “chicken dance”. Bush and Cheney will do exactly what they want under the cover of this report and what we will have is essentially “Stay the Course” redux. What we have witnessed is an exercise in what is known as “Turd Polishing”.


UPDATE: Here is what Russ Feingold has to say about the report.
The fact is this commission was composed apparently entirely of people who did not have the judgment to oppose this Iraq war in the first place, and did not have the judgment to realize it was not a wise move in the fight against terrorism. So that's who is doing this report. Then I looked at the list of who testified before them. There is virtually no one who opposed the war in the first place. Virtually no one who has been really calling for a different strategy that goes for a global approach to the war on terrorism. So this is really a Washington inside job and it shows not in the description of what's happened - that's fairly accurate - but it shows in the recommendations. It's been called a classic Washington compromise that does not do the job of extricating us from Iraq in a way that we can deal with the issues in Southeast Asia, in Afghanistan, and in Somalia which are every bit as important as what is happening in Iraq. This report does not do the job and it's because it was not composed of a real representative group of Americans who believe what the American people showed in the election, which is that it's time for us to have a timetable to bring the troops out of Iraq.
I rest my case.